Namespaces
Variants
Views
Actions

Difference between revisions of "cpp/freestanding"

From cppreference.com
< cpp
m (→‎Requirements on standard library headers: ~{{header}})
m (→‎Notes: +fresh FTMs, some wording update.)
 
(15 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 12: Line 12:
 
{{!}}-
 
{{!}}-
 
{{!}} Under a ''freestanding'' implementation, it is implementation-defined whether a program can have more than one [[cpp/thread|thread of execution]].
 
{{!}} Under a ''freestanding'' implementation, it is implementation-defined whether a program can have more than one [[cpp/thread|thread of execution]].
−
{{!}} Under a ''hosted'' implementation, a C++ program can have more than one [[cpp/thread|thread]] running concurrently.
+
{{!}} Under a ''hosted'' implementation, a C++ program can have more than one {{lt|cpp/thread}} running concurrently.
 
{{!)}}
 
{{!)}}
 
}}
 
}}
Line 22: Line 22:
 
! ''freestanding'' !! ''hosted''
 
! ''freestanding'' !! ''hosted''
 
|-
 
|-
−
| In a ''freestanding'' implementation, it is implementation-defined whether a program is required to define a {{ltt|cpp/language/main function|main}} function. Start-up and termination is implementation-defined; start-up contains the execution of [[cpp/language/constructor|constructor]]s for objects of [[cpp/language/scope#Namespace scope|namespace scope]] with static storage duration; termination contains the execution of [[cpp/language/destructor|destructors]] for objects with static [[cpp/language/storage duration|storage duration]].
+
| In a ''freestanding'' implementation, it is implementation-defined whether a program is required to define a {{ltt|cpp/language/main function|main}} function. Start-up and termination is implementation-defined; start-up contains the execution of {{lt|cpp/language/constructor}}s for objects of {{lsd|cpp/language/scope#Namespace scope}} with static storage duration; termination contains the execution of {{lt|cpp/language/destructor}}s for objects with static {{lt|cpp/language/storage duration}}.
−
| In a ''hosted'' implementation, a program must contain a global function called {{ltt|cpp/language/main function|main}}. Executing a program starts a main [[cpp/thread|thread of execution]] in which the {{tt|main}} function is invoked, and in which variables of static [[cpp/language/storage duration|storage duration]] might be initialized and destroyed.
+
| In a ''hosted'' implementation, a program must contain a global function called {{ltt|cpp/language/main function|main}}. Executing a program starts a main [[cpp/thread|thread of execution]] in which the {{tt|main}} function is invoked, and in which variables of static {{lt|cpp/language/storage duration}} might be initialized and destroyed.
 
|}
 
|}
  
 
{{anchor|header requirements}}
 
{{anchor|header requirements}}
 +
 
===Requirements on [[cpp/header|standard library headers]]===
 
===Requirements on [[cpp/header|standard library headers]]===
 +
A ''freestanding'' implementation has an implementation-defined set of headers. This set includes at least the headers in the following table.
  
−
A ''freestanding'' implementation has an implementation-defined set of headers. This set includes at least the headers in the following table:
+
For partially freestanding headers, freestanding implementations only needs to provide part of the entities in the corresponding synopsis:
 +
* If an entity is commented {{c/core|// freestanding}}, it is guaranteed to be provided.
 +
{{rrev|since=c++26|
 +
* If an entity (function or function template) is commented {{c/core|// freestanding-deleted}}, it is guaranteed to be either provided or deleted.
 +
}}
  
−
{| class="wikitable"
+
{|class="wikitable sortable"
−
|+ style="padding:6px;"| Headers required for a ''freestanding'' implementation
+
|+style="padding:6px;"|Headers required for a freestanding implementation
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Types || {{header|cstddef}}
+
!Library
 +
!Component
 +
!Headers
 +
!{{nbsp}}Freestanding{{nbsp}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Implementation properties || {{header|limits}}<br />{{header|cfloat}} {{header|climits}} {{mark since c++11}}<br />{{header|version}} {{mark since c++20}}
+
|rowspan=13|{{ls|cpp/utility#Language support}}
 +
|Common definitions
 +
|{{header|cstddef}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Integer types || {{header|cstdint}} {{mark since c++11}}
+
|C standard library
 +
|{{header|cstdlib}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Start and termination || {{header|cstdlib}} {{mark|partial}}<ref>The supplied version of the {{header|cstdlib}} shall declare at least the functions {{lc|std::abort}}, {{lc|std::atexit}}, {{lc|std::exit}}{{rev inl|since=c++11|, {{lc|std::at_quick_exit}} and {{lc|std::quick_exit}}}}.</ref>
+
|Implementation properties
 +
|{{header|cfloat}}<br>{{header|climits}} {{mark since c++11}}<br>{{header|limits}}<br>{{header|version}} {{mark since c++20}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Dynamic memory management || {{header|new}}
+
|Integer types
 +
|{{header|cstdint}} {{mark since c++11}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Type identification || {{header|typeinfo}}
+
|Dynamic memory management
 +
|{{header|new}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Source location || {{header|source_location}} {{mark since c++20}}
+
|Type identification
 +
|{{header|typeinfo}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Exception handling || {{header|exception}}
+
|Source location
 +
|{{header|source_location}} {{mark since c++20}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Initializer lists || {{header|initializer_list}} {{mark since c++11}}
+
|Exception handling
 +
|{{header|exception}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Comparisons || {{header|compare}} {{mark since c++20}}
+
|Initializer lists
 +
|{{header|initializer_list}} {{mark since c++11}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Coroutines support || {{header|coroutine}} {{mark since c++20}}
+
|Comparisons
 +
|{{header|compare}} {{mark since c++20}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Other runtime support || {{header|cstdarg}}
+
|Coroutines support
 +
|{{header|coroutine}} {{mark since c++20}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Fundamental library concepts || {{header|concepts}} {{mark since c++20}}
+
|Other runtime support
 +
|{{header|cstdarg}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Type traits || {{header|type_traits}} {{mark since c++11}}
+
|Debugging support
 +
|{{header|debugging}} {{mark since c++26}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Bit manipulation || {{header|bit}} {{mark since c++20}}
+
|colspan=2|[[cpp/concepts|Concepts]]
 +
|{{header|concepts}} {{mark since c++20}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Atomics || {{header|atomic}} {{mark since c++11}}<ref>{{rev inl|since=c++20|Support for always lock-free integral atomic types and presence of type aliases {{lc|std::atomic_signed_lock_free}} and {{lc|std::atomic_unsigned_lock_free}} are implementation-defined in a freestanding implementation.}}</ref>
+
|rowspan=2|[[cpp/error|Diagnostics]]
 +
|Error numbers
 +
|{{header|cerrno}} {{mark since c++26}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Utility components || {{header|utility}} {{mark since c++23}}
+
|System error support
 +
|{{header|system_error}} {{mark since c++26}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Tuples || {{header|tuple}} {{mark since c++23}}
+
|[[cpp/memory|Memory management]]{{nbsp}}
 +
|Memory
 +
|{{header|memory}} {{mark since c++23}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Memory || {{header|memory}} {{mark since c++23}} {{mark|partial}}
+
|rowspan=2|[[cpp/meta|Metaprogramming]]
 +
|Type traits
 +
|{{header|type_traits}} {{mark since c++11}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Function objects || {{header|functional}} {{mark since c++23}} {{mark|partial}}
+
|Compile-time rational arithmetic{{nbsp}}
 +
|{{header|ratio}} {{mark since c++23}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Compile-time rational arithmetic || {{header|ratio}} {{mark since c++23}}
+
|rowspan=5|[[cpp/utility#General-purpose utilities|General utilities]]
 +
|Utility components
 +
|{{header|utility}} {{mark since c++23}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Iterators library || {{header|iterator}} {{mark since c++23}} {{mark|partial}}
+
|Tuples
 +
|{{header|tuple}} {{mark since c++23}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Ranges library || {{header|ranges}} {{mark since c++23}} {{mark|partial}}
+
|Function objects
 +
|{{header|functional}} {{mark since c++20}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 
|-
 
|-
−
| Deprecated headers || {{header|ciso646}} {{header|cstdalign}} {{header|cstdbool}} {{mark life|since=c++11|until=c++20}}
+
|Primitive numeric conversions
 +
|{{header|charconv}} {{mark since c++26}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 +
|-
 +
|Bit manipulation
 +
|{{header|bit}} {{mark since c++20}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 +
|-
 +
|rowspan=2|[[cpp/string|Strings]]
 +
|String classes
 +
|{{header|string}} {{mark since c++26}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 +
|-
 +
|Null-terminated<br>sequence utilities
 +
|{{header|cstring}} {{mark since c++26}}<br>{{header|cwchar}} {{mark since c++26}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 +
|-
 +
|colspan=2|[[cpp/iterator|Iterators]]
 +
|{{header|iterator}} {{mark since c++23}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 +
|-
 +
|colspan=2|[[cpp/ranges|Ranges]]
 +
|{{header|ranges}} {{mark since c++23}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 +
|-
 +
|[[cpp/numeric|Numerics]]
 +
|Mathematical functions<br>for floating-point types
 +
|{{header|cmath}} {{mark since c++26}}
 +
|{{maybe|Partial}}
 +
|-
 +
|[[cpp/thread|Concurrency support]]
 +
|Atomics
 +
|{{header|atomic}} {{mark since c++11}}
 +
|{{yes|{{nbsp|4}}All<ref>{{rev inl|since=c++20|Support for always lock-free integral atomic types and presence of type aliases {{lc|std::atomic_signed_lock_free}} and {{lc|std::atomic_unsigned_lock_free}} are implementation-defined in a freestanding implementation.}}</ref>}}
 +
|-
 +
|colspan=2|'''Deprecated''' headers
 +
|{{header|ciso646}} {{mark until c++20}}<br>{{header|cstdalign}} {{mark life|since=c++11|until=c++20}}{{nbsp}}<br>{{header|cstdbool}} {{mark life|since=c++11|until=c++20}}
 +
|{{yes|All}}
 
|}
 
|}
 
<references/>
 
<references/>
  
 
===Notes===
 
===Notes===
 +
Some compiler vendors may not fully support freestanding implementation. For example, GCC libstdc++ has had implementation and build issues before version 13, while LLVM libcxx and MSVC STL do not support freestanding.
 +
 +
In C++23, many features are made freestanding with partial headers. However, it is still up for discussion in WG21 whether some headers will be made freestanding in the future standards. Regardless, containers like {{lc|std::vector|vector}}, {{lc|std::list|list}}, {{lc|std::deque|deque}}, and {{lc|std::map|map}} will never be freestanding due to their dependencies on exceptions and heap.
  
−
Compiler vendors might not correctly support freestanding implementation, for either implementation issues, or just ignoring freestanding as a whole (LLVM libcxx and msvc stl).
+
GCC 13 provides more headers, such as {{header|optional}}, {{header|span}}, {{header|array}}, and {{header|bitset}}, for freestanding, although these headers may not be portable or provide the same capabilities as a hosted implementation. It is better to avoid using them in a freestanding environment, even if the toolchain provides them.
  
−
Many features will be freestanding in C++23 but with partial headers. Whether array would be freestanding in the future is under discussion.
+
{{ftm begin|sort=yes}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_feature_test_macros|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding feature test macros}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_algorithm|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|algorithm}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_array|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|array}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_char_traits|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{lc|std::char_traits}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_charconv|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|charconv}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_cstdlib|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|cstdlib}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_cstring|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|cstring}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_cwchar|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|cwchar}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_errc|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{lc|std::errc}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_expected|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|expected}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_functional|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|functional}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_iterator|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|iterator}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_mdspan|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|mdspan}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_memory|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|memory}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_numeric|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|numeric}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_optional|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|optional}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_ranges|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|ranges}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_ratio|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|ratio}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_string_view|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|string_view}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_tuple|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|tuple}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_utility|value=202306L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|utility}}}}
 +
{{ftm|__cpp_lib_freestanding_variant|value=202311L|std=C++26|freestanding {{header|variant}}}}
 +
{{ftm end}}
  
 
===References===
 
===References===
Line 130: Line 251:
 
{{dr list begin}}
 
{{dr list begin}}
 
{{dr list item|wg=cwg|dr=1938|std=C++98|before=an implementation did not need<br>to document whether it is hosted|after=made the implementation kind implementation-<br>defined (thus requires a documentation)}}
 
{{dr list item|wg=cwg|dr=1938|std=C++98|before=an implementation did not need<br>to document whether it is hosted|after=made the implementation kind implementation-<br>defined (thus requires a documentation)}}
−
{{dr list item|wg=lwg|dr=3653|std=C++20|before=<coroutine> is freestanding,<br> but uses std::hash which is not|after=Fixed in C++23 with <functional><br>being partial freestanding}}
+
{{dr list item|wg=lwg|dr=3653|paper=P1642R11|std=C++20|before={{header|coroutine}} is freestanding, but<br>uses {{lc|std::hash}} which was not|after=made {{header|functional}} being<br> partially freestanding}}
 
{{dr list end}}
 
{{dr list end}}
  

Latest revision as of 23:40, 29 December 2023

 
C++
 

There are two kinds of implementations defined by the C++ standard: hosted and freestanding implementations. For hosted implementations, the set of standard library headers required by the C++ standard is much larger than for freestanding ones. In a freestanding implementation, execution may happen without an operating system.

The kind of the implementation is implementation-defined. The macro __STDC_HOSTED__ is predefined to 1 for hosted implementations and 0 for freestanding implementations.(since C++11)

Contents

Requirements on multi-threaded executions and data races

freestanding hosted
Under a freestanding implementation, it is implementation-defined whether a program can have more than one thread of execution. Under a hosted implementation, a C++ program can have more than one thread running concurrently.
(since C++11)

[edit] Requirements on the main function

freestanding hosted
In a freestanding implementation, it is implementation-defined whether a program is required to define a main function. Start-up and termination is implementation-defined; start-up contains the execution of constructors for objects of namespace scope with static storage duration; termination contains the execution of destructors for objects with static storage duration. In a hosted implementation, a program must contain a global function called main. Executing a program starts a main thread of execution in which the main function is invoked, and in which variables of static storage duration might be initialized and destroyed.

[edit] Requirements on standard library headers

A freestanding implementation has an implementation-defined set of headers. This set includes at least the headers in the following table.

For partially freestanding headers, freestanding implementations only needs to provide part of the entities in the corresponding synopsis:

  • If an entity is commented // freestanding, it is guaranteed to be provided.
  • If an entity (function or function template) is commented // freestanding-deleted, it is guaranteed to be either provided or deleted.
(since C++26)
Headers required for a freestanding implementation
Library Component Headers  Freestanding 
Language support Common definitions <cstddef> All
C standard library <cstdlib> Partial
Implementation properties <cfloat>
<climits> (since C++11)
<limits>
<version> (since C++20) 		All
Integer types <cstdint> (since C++11) All
Dynamic memory management <new> All
Type identification <typeinfo> All
Source location <source_location> (since C++20) All
Exception handling <exception> All
Initializer lists <initializer_list> (since C++11) All
Comparisons <compare> (since C++20) All
Coroutines support <coroutine> (since C++20) All
Other runtime support <cstdarg> All
Debugging support <debugging> (since C++26) All
Concepts <concepts> (since C++20) All
Diagnostics Error numbers <cerrno> (since C++26) Partial
System error support <system_error> (since C++26) Partial
Memory management  Memory <memory> (since C++23) Partial
Metaprogramming Type traits <type_traits> (since C++11) All
Compile-time rational arithmetic  <ratio> (since C++23) All
General utilities Utility components <utility> (since C++23) All
Tuples <tuple> (since C++23) All
Function objects <functional> (since C++20) Partial
Primitive numeric conversions <charconv> (since C++26) Partial
Bit manipulation <bit> (since C++20) All
Strings String classes <string> (since C++26) Partial
Null-terminated
sequence utilities 		<cstring> (since C++26)
<cwchar> (since C++26) 		Partial
Iterators <iterator> (since C++23) Partial
Ranges <ranges> (since C++23) Partial
Numerics Mathematical functions
for floating-point types 		<cmath> (since C++26) Partial
Concurrency support Atomics <atomic> (since C++11)     All[1]
Deprecated headers <ciso646> (until C++20)
<cstdalign> (since C++11)(until C++20) 
<cstdbool> (since C++11)(until C++20) 		All
  1. ↑ Support for always lock-free integral atomic types and presence of type aliases std::atomic_signed_lock_free and std::atomic_unsigned_lock_free are implementation-defined in a freestanding implementation.(since C++20)

[edit] Notes

Some compiler vendors may not fully support freestanding implementation. For example, GCC libstdc++ has had implementation and build issues before version 13, while LLVM libcxx and MSVC STL do not support freestanding.

In C++23, many features are made freestanding with partial headers. However, it is still up for discussion in WG21 whether some headers will be made freestanding in the future standards. Regardless, containers like vector, list, deque, and map will never be freestanding due to their dependencies on exceptions and heap.

GCC 13 provides more headers, such as <optional>, <span>, <array>, and <bitset>, for freestanding, although these headers may not be portable or provide the same capabilities as a hosted implementation. It is better to avoid using them in a freestanding environment, even if the toolchain provides them.

Feature-test macro Value Std Feature
__cpp_lib_freestanding_feature_test_macros 202306L (C++26) freestanding feature test macros
__cpp_lib_freestanding_algorithm 202311L (C++26) freestanding <algorithm>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_array 202311L (C++26) freestanding <array>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_char_traits 202306L (C++26) freestanding std::char_traits
__cpp_lib_freestanding_charconv 202306L (C++26) freestanding <charconv>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_cstdlib 202306L (C++26) freestanding <cstdlib>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_cstring 202311L (C++26) freestanding <cstring>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_cwchar 202306L (C++26) freestanding <cwchar>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_errc 202306L (C++26) freestanding std::errc
__cpp_lib_freestanding_expected 202311L (C++26) freestanding <expected>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_functional 202306L (C++26) freestanding <functional>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_iterator 202306L (C++26) freestanding <iterator>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_mdspan 202311L (C++26) freestanding <mdspan>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_memory 202306L (C++26) freestanding <memory>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_numeric 202311L (C++26) freestanding <numeric>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_optional 202311L (C++26) freestanding <optional>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_ranges 202306L (C++26) freestanding <ranges>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_ratio 202306L (C++26) freestanding <ratio>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_string_view 202311L (C++26) freestanding <string_view>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_tuple 202306L (C++26) freestanding <tuple>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_utility 202306L (C++26) freestanding <utility>
__cpp_lib_freestanding_variant 202311L (C++26) freestanding <variant>

[edit] References

  • C++23 standard (ISO/IEC 14882:2024):
  • 4.1 Implementation compliance [intro.compliance] (p: 10)
  • 6.9.2 Multi-threaded executions and data races [intro.multithread] (p: 84)
  • 6.9.3.1 main function [basic.start.main] (p: 89)
  • 16.4.2.5 Freestanding implementations [compliance] (p: 483)
  • C++20 standard (ISO/IEC 14882:2020):
  • 4.1 Implementation compliance [intro.compliance] (p: 7)
  • 6.9.2 Multi-threaded executions and data races [intro.multithread] (p: 77)
  • 6.9.3.1 main function [basic.start.main] (p: 82)
  • 16.5.1.3 Freestanding implementations [compliance] (p: 470)
  • C++17 standard (ISO/IEC 14882:2017):
  • 4.1 Implementation compliance [intro.compliance] (p: 5)
  • 4.7 Multi-threaded executions and data races [intro.multithread] (p: 15)
  • 6.6.1 main function [basic.start.main] (p: 66)
  • 20.5.1.3 Freestanding implementations [compliance] (p: 458)
  • C++14 standard (ISO/IEC 14882:2014):
  • 1.4 Implementation compliance [intro.compliance] (p: 5)
  • 1.10 Multi-threaded executions and data races [intro.multithread] (p: 11)
  • 3.6.1 Main function [basic.start.main] (p: 62)
  • 17.6.1.3 Freestanding implementations [compliance] (p: 441)
  • C++11 standard (ISO/IEC 14882:2011):
  • 1.4 Implementation compliance [intro.compliance] (p: 5)
  • 1.10 Multi-threaded executions and data races [intro.multithread] (p: 11)
  • 3.6.1 Main function [basic.start.main] (p: 58)
  • 17.6.1.3 Freestanding implementations [compliance] (p: 408)
  • C++03 standard (ISO/IEC 14882:2003):
  • 1.4 Implementation compliance [intro.compliance] (p: 3)
  • 3.6.1 Main function [basic.start.main] (p: 43)
  • 17.4.1.3 Freestanding implementations [lib.compliance] (p: 326)

[edit] Defect reports

The following behavior-changing defect reports were applied retroactively to previously published C++ standards.

DR Applied to Behavior as published Correct behavior
CWG 1938 C++98 an implementation did not need
to document whether it is hosted 		made the implementation kind implementation-
defined (thus requires a documentation)
LWG 3653
(P1642R11) 		C++20 <coroutine> is freestanding, but
uses std::hash which was not 		made <functional> being
partially freestanding

[edit] See also

C documentation for Conformance
Retrieved from "https://en.cppreference.com/mwiki/index.php?title=cpp/freestanding&oldid=167777"